Unraveling a Mystery Photo, from Oklahoma to French Lick

Lori Fry, holding one of the mystery photos that led her from Oklahoma to French Lick.


You know those mystery-in-a-box challenges that come delivered to your front door? Lori Fry found herself holding a real-life mystery-in-a-box.

Cracking the code guided her all the way from Oklahoma to French Lick.

First, a little background. Lori is from Muskogee, Oklahoma and she’s in the process of writing a book about her paternal grandmother’s brother, Bert, who passed away in 1954 in an oil well explosion. When she was dying, Lori’s grandmother told her: “Please promise me you will not forget my beloved Bert.”

But she’d never heard her grandmother say more than three words about Bert.

“She said everything you need to know is in these boxes in a trunk. I had this trunk that said M.A.P., Orleans, Indiana. I thought, who the heck in my family is from Orleans, Indiana? I thought we were all Okies,” Lori says. “My head is just spinning at this point. I put it aside for a few years.”

But then Lori cracked open the trunk again and leafed through some of the photos and postcards inside.

She pieced together that “M.A.P.” stood for Mary Angeline Phillips, her great-great-great-grandmother. (She’s the woman in the far right in the photo above dated 1910-11.) Mary Angeline is sitting with her daughter Lydia Ellen (Phillips) Pace (Lori’s great-great grandmother) and two young girls (Lori’s great-grandmother and great-aunt) on the lawn of a stately building in the early 1900s.

Folks from Indiana would recognize it pretty easily as French Lick Springs Hotel, because it still looks very similar 100 years ago to now. But Lori had no clue what the building was or where it was located. Nothing of that scale would have existed in Oklahoma at that time, since it had just become an official state. In search of answers, Lori took the photos to the genealogy department of her local library.

Lori handed the local historian the photo, and asked if that building was somewhere in Oklahoma.

“She said no, but she hands this book to me and says, is that it? And it’s the postcard edition of the history of French Lick. It has a picture of the hotel on the front cover. That book helped me solve a hundred years of family genealogy mysteries.”

Lori got the chance during her visit to re-enact old family photos from her collection, including this one in the back of the hotel next to the iconic Pluto Spring House. Compare it to the vintage photo below, which has another smaller spring house in the background which has since been removed. 

At first, Lori’s thought was that French Lick Springs Hotel probably wasn’t still around, but maybe it’d be fun to visit Indiana to see where her ancestors once lived and the hotel once stood.

“A quick Google search…this place is still there?!” Lori recalls with a laugh. “It was really exciting to find out that, hey, this is a place I can go and visit, this is a place I can relive some history, have a connection with.”

Lori discovered that part of her family was from Bedford and Orleans, Indiana, dating back to the early 1800s. Lydia Ellen Phillips was a widower who lost her first husband to typhoid fever, then left Indiana  to make a claim in Oklahoma’s Cherokee strip land run in 1893.

Mattie (Pace) Jones in the French Lick Springs Hotel
gardens by the Pluto Spring.
Lydia returned to Indiana in 1901 and connected with her second husband, John Edward Pace, at French Lick Springs Hotel — Lori found a few of their old love letters in the box and found out they loved to walk the gardens together. Lori also discovered a picture of John’s sister, Mattie (Pace) Jones, who was apparently a fan of the foul-smelling mineral water that guests enjoyed at the hotel and also took home in bottles. Written on the back: “Mattie loves that nasty Pluto Water, but she also drinks her share at home.”

Earlier this summer, Lori jumped at opportunity to make the 600+ mile trek to French Lick — that once-mysterious building…in that black-and-white photo…in the bottom of the trunk…where this crazy puzzle all began.

“We were blown away. That place is so beautiful,” Lori says. “This hotel has some serious history, and it’s crazy the amount of things that happened there.”

And now Lori has a chapter of her own to add.